HELP SAVE OUR WOOD BENCHES!!!
Keep Balboa Island Quaint and Historical
HELP SAVE OUR WOOD BENCHES!!!
Keep Balboa Island Quaint and Historical
Recently you should have received a ballot from the City of Newport Beach Public Works department for the selection of benches on Balboa Island.
There are only three benches to select on this ballot. Any other option (such as a write in) will technically NOT be counted, as only the three benches listed on the ballot were approved for this selection/voting process -- two PLASTIC Benches (HDPE) and one WOOD bench.
The wood bench on the ballot is the exact same bench located on the 200 and 300 blocks of Marine Ave. The Marine Ave bench is made from solid Jatoba wood (common name Brazilian Cherry Wood). Brazilian Cherrywood is 400% times denser than teak and per the US Forest Product Lab has a rating of 20-25 year lifespan. Unlike decks which have extensive under-support systems, plastic outdoor furniture tends to stain, sag and warp with a typical lifespan of 5-7 years, especially in salty and damp areas such as Balboa Island.
BASED ON YOUR BALLOT SELECTION, the look and charm of Balboa Island is at stake!
Unlike plastic composite decks that have support foundations, plastic benches tend to warp and sag over time
Unlike wood, plastic gets brittle from the sun and wind
Plastic 'absorbs' stains from airplane fuel, sunscreen, ketchup and oils
Unlike wood, you cannot sand or restore dents in plastic
Plastic is easy to graffiti on and cannot be removed or sanded off like wood.
Plastic furniture fades in the sun and unlike wood, can't be refinished, restained or painted. They often end up in our landfill !! :(
The beautiful and historic wooden benches that have graced Balboa Island for many years are were the result of many generous donations from private citizens, often made to memorialize a loved ones. According to a community survey, residents and visitors overwhelmingly voted
(>90 in favor of keeping our WOOD benches (click the "LEARN MORE" button to the right to see the poll within the report).
Why the ballot then you might ask?
The short answer is that Public Works' ultimate goal is to remove our wood benches so that they can also eliminate the donor plaques!!
BIPA has been an advocate in maintaining and retaining our wood benches and donor plaques. Not only are the wood benches comfortable, sturdy, sustainable, made right here in the USA, and part of our island charm and history, our extensive research concluded that:
· The City of Newport Beach has the funds to properly maintain our most cherished assets on Balboa Island, such as the wood benches. (See Report - pg. 92)
· Public Works has NOT been maintaining our wood benches as they had agreed to do, withholding maintenance for several years now; thereby accelerating the end of their “useful life” in order to eliminate the bench donor plaque program.
· The Public Works plan (and their single bid received for annual maintenance by an engineering contractor in LA), was presented to Council in 2020 which cost Substantially more than BIPA’s recommendation/plan. (See Report - pg. 93-94)
· Research has shown that replacing our wood benches with faux wood such as plastic (HDPE) is greatly inferior in comparison to Jatoba (Brazilian Cherry Wood ) in the areas of sustainability (lifespan), durability, safety, cost, susceptibility to warpage, sagging and staining, not to mention comfort. (See Report - pg. 87-91)
· Funds that were intended to maintain Balboa Island wood benches have been redirected and used to maintain other areas in Newport Beach and not Balboa Island. (See Report - pg. 69)
· The original procured donor funded benches and the additional $1,000 previously paid for initial maintenance by donors saved the City of Newport Beach almost $250,000.00!
Over the last 18 months, a dedicated team of Balboa Island volunteers conducted extensive research on the benches and prepared a comprehensive report which was submitted to the PB&R Bench Committee. Here you will find factual information regarding the bench history on Balboa Island, bids, product analysis and other interesting facts.
Click on "Learn More" tab below to get the REPORT.
We are dedicated to improving the lives of those in our community. Your contribution today helps us make a difference.
Help our cause and donate now
To protect Balboa Island’s historical uniqueness and to maintain the integrity and character of Marine Avenue, Balboa Island’s iconic ‘main street’. The Balboa Island Preservation Association is a community led organization to achieve our preservation mission for the enjoyment and benefit of Balboa Island residents, merchants, visitors and for future generations.
Are you passionate about what we're doing? Would you like to be a part of preserving and protecting the character of Balboa Island and historical Marine Ave, including our landmark trees? We're looking for additional volunteers to help us make our vision a reality. Your involvement will make a difference!
Scroll down to bottom of page and join BIPA TODAY!
IMPORTANT- Please take our poll and cast your VOTE NOW for Balboa Island benches and street lamps listed below. We will share the outcome with the City of Newport Beach.
Our unique and charming benches on Balboa Island are at risk! Through BIPA's efforts, we have received historical data on the benches, as well as current costs to maintain our beloved benches. BIPA recently restored one of the benches on Marine Ave which was refinished with a quality and affordable approach compared to the cost that the City received from one bidder (see the final product above!). The Marine Avenue Brazilian Cherry benches are far superior than plastic that warps and brakes or concrete that cracks and chips. Because of its natural oils, Brazilian Cherry benches only needs periodic resealing. Unlike a varnish, a sealer will preserve the color while being breathable, letting the natural oils move to the surface for protection. Once sealed, the benches require little care. In July 2004, the City Council unanimously chose these benches based on a joint recommendation from the Public Works, Planning and General Services Departments. The benches are made in the USA by D.M. Braun & Company and the benches and litter receptacles cost $74,688. The cost of the benches was covered by donations from the public and the balance of the Marine Avenue benches were later donated in 2009. The donor cost in 2009 was $1,156.00 per bench. Now the City wants to replace the benches with concrete or plastic products due to an outlandish bid they received to maintain our benches. BIPA's restoration approach is a significant savings to the tax payers and keeps Marine Ave and Balboa Island unique and charming.
How does history affect us and what story does it tell?
The street lights on Marine Ave tell us a story about simpler days gone by and the soft luminous glow remind us of gatherings with friends and neighbors over many years.
The historic street lamps on Marine Avenue have graced Balboa Island since the early 1930s. (See the photos in More Info/Photo Gallery.) They have survived the City’s Streetlight Replacement Program, but are now under threat from the City’s infrastructure plans (including replacement of “obsolete” street lamps with LED lighting) for Marine Avenue reconstruction and other Balboa Island development plans. Ironically, other cities have purchased similar lamps to give instant character to their downtown's. BIPA is fighting to preserve our street lamps as part of the historic charm of Balboa Island.
Sternberg lighting, established in Chicago in 1923, is an iconic light pole and glass fixture found on many historic main streets in America and the Marine Ave style “Avenue” was one of the most popular in US history.
Don't let the City remove our lights just to see them sold to another main street that values these historical and charming artifacts. We can keep our unique street lights by just changing out the filaments, if need be. I would argue that the soft glow of our street lights are far better then the harsh, eye burning florescent bulbs of today!
Gently swirling among us, our historical and City designated "Special Trees" have provided our community with a sense of place for more than ten decades and anchors where we call home; one of the most beautiful locations in the Country.
The community was told our trees must go to make room for a "new look", but BIPA has fought for historical preservation of this special place, and truth and transparency for over two years. BIPA proved that our trees are stable and per PB&R, no more Marine Ave Special Trees will be removed without scientific proof and evidence that the trees are a threat to the community.
UPDATE: Due to Corona Virus restrictions, the advanced testing planned for March 16 &17, 2020 has been postponed until further notice.